JobSearchMarketing wrote home praise about Etsy's careers page. It's always interesting to see what people outside of Etsy think about the site or even just parts of it, its philosophy, its presentation on the internet or the people behind it all. JobSearchMarketing is written by a Media Sales Strategy manager at Yahoo! HotJobs.
The post is certainly written with regards to tech specialists recruiting, but given I was looking for, say, a MarComms job with Etsy (these openings are currently unavailable, but it doesn't seem clear from their openings page whether they've been put on ice as long as Etsy builds up Engineering, or whether the team indeed is complete now; Etsy was looking for e.g., a PR specialist with a "killer rolodex"...), there is some info I would be looking for in vain, while other would simply be too tech-heavy. You can't please 'em all, as the saying goes. Etsy, the community-focused internet site, is definitely tech-driven.
ad 3: in my opinion, whether an "About Us" page talks about the people, not the company, always depends on the company's focus and goals. In the case of Etsy and its distinctive philosophy, presenting the staff only makes sense (right now, I can't even think of what else to present there. They used to have a huge text blurb about visions and some missions).
A slight minus is that even with visual content, About Us is never really up-to-date.
Though a really smart and fresh idea, many handwritings are, well, indecipherable. But yes, they do add a personal touch and correspond really well to the overall idea behind this page. I've been wondering what this is going to be changed into once Etsy outgrows a number of, say, 100 employees? Right now they're around 40ish.
ad 4: In my opinion, the graphs just scratch the surface and say not much about the real standing and the success of Etsy as a company; but then again, the really interesting figures are hidden even from sellers.
ad 5/solve a problem: that's what Google and many others have been doing since years. But yes, it might weed out the trash, and Etsy is known for writing all their software from scratch (the cynics out there are known to have commented "reinventing the wheel").








